Roughly: city sewer = $400-$1,200/year in fees forever. Septic = $300-$650 every 3-5 years for pumping, plus rare repairs. Over 30 years, septic typically saves $5K-$20K, but requires homeowner attention.
More detail
Greater Cincinnati 30-year cost comparison for a typical 4-person household. City sewer: $50-$100/month average sewer fee = $18,000-$36,000 over 30 years, plus a one-time tap fee at connection ($1,500-$4,500). Septic: $300-$650 pump every 3-5 years = $1,800-$6,500 for pumping over 30 years, plus typical repair allowance of $3,000-$8,000 for component replacement (effluent filter, baffle, distribution box, lift pump, aerator), plus drain field replacement once mid-life ($8,000-$15,000) for a true 30-year cost in the $13,000-$30,000 range. Net septic savings: $5,000-$20,000 over 30 years for the engaged homeowner. The hidden cost of septic is the maintenance attention; homeowners who skip pump cycles or neglect annual filter cleaning typically pay 2-3x the bottom-line maintenance budget through accelerated drain-field failure. Cincinnati 30-year cost reality: the savings on septic over sewer accrue mostly to homeowners who maintain their systems on schedule. Households that skip pump cycles, plant aggressive trees near the field, or send sump-pump discharge to the septic typically pay 2-3x the bottom-line maintenance budget through accelerated drain-field failure. The savings are not automatic; they require homeowner attention and discipline.